This is an ACCA “violent felony” issue case. So here we go down the rabbit hole again to a realm where we must close our eyes as judges to what we know as men and women. It is a pretend place in which a crime that the defendant committed violently is transformed into a non-violent one because other defendants at other times may have been convicted, or future defendants could be convicted, of violating the same statute without violence. Curiouser and curiouser it has all become, as the holding we must enter in this case shows. Still we are required to follow the rabbit.So, who is the rabbit? The rule of law?
Tuesday, November 07, 2017
Another ACCA case
Here's an interesting introduction by Chief Judge Carnes in U.S. v. Davis: