By David Oscar Markus
DOJ charged James Comey again today. Third time. This one is a two-count information in D.C. alleging he leaked national defense information in October 2016. It was filed under seal on October 5, 2026. No grand jury. No waiver. DOJ says the point is to toll the statute of limitations while it keeps investigating.
Here is the information. Here is Comey’s motion to dismiss. And here is the government’s response.
DOJ defends not going to the grand jury as a “widely recognized practice.”
During COVID, grand juries in our district stopped meeting. Prosecutors filed waiverless informations to beat the clock, and about ten defendants got caught up in it. I argued one of those cases, United States v. B.G.G. (I wrote about it here.)
In B.G.G., the government filed an information against Dr. Bart Gatz three days before the statute ran. It knew he would not waive indictment. It served him at 6:33 p.m. on the last day. Then it waited. Nearly three years later, it got an indictment.
Judge Middlebrooks rightfully didn’t buy it. An unconsented information does not toll the statute. The government had admitted the information could not start a prosecution. Its only job was to stop the clock. Big props to the Judge. He got it right. It was such a powerful order that the government did not appeal it, and instead chose to defend judges who went the other way. And in 2025 the Eleventh Circuit sided with the government in United States v. Webster. Even there, a concurring judge warned about prosecutorial manipulation and pointed to Gatz as the example.
In these cases, there was a pandemic. The grand juries were shut down. Comey’s information was filed in October 2026 when grand juries are available.
Comey also has an argument the pandemic cases didn’t. The five-year statute, § 3282, talks about an information being “instituted.” The ten-year espionage statute does not. It requires an indictment. So the five-year clock ran long ago, and the ten-year one demands a grand jury. The Fifth Amendment requires a grand jury for a felony unless the defendant waives. An information that can’t be prosecuted shouldn’t be able to freeze the clock. And if you can’t get a grand jury to indict in ten years, that tells you something.
8 comments:
The U.S. government has played these games since the beginning of time. Now, when the tactics are used again poor James Comey, everyone is up in arms. Comical.
Comey had this coming and he should rightfully spend all of his money defending bogus federal prosecutions.
We should take some time to spotlight how often the DoJ does this to regular people who have no choice but to let the system have its way with them.
What a dumb comment. DOJ at the moment sucks. And past / other injustices do not justify more injustice. What a waste of resources, personal, prosecutorial, and judicial. For what exactly? To please the rapist-in-chief?
James Comey deserves every piece of shit thrown his way. He deliberately threw the election for Trump. Let him rot.
"should rightfully spend all of his money defending bogus federal prosecutions."
Said un-facetiously and without a shred of hesitation.
Absolutely remarkable that this is where we (or even some of us) are now.
Hate to break it to ya, but that election was lost by a lot more votes than the number of people who even know what the Comey report is or says. Regardless of politics or the past, what the Doj is doing to Comey right now is utterly wrong, embarrassing, and shameful.
Has anyone read Comey's book. Its fascinating for so many reasons. He served Rudy Guliiani in S/NY and the DAG with Bush and then FBI director for Bush and Obama. As FBI director he took the charging power away from the AG and gave himself that power in declining charges against Clinton. But he did not just put on an AG hat. He smeared a presidential candidate to the public how he would never hire her, etc. 10 days before the election he writes a memo that the investigation into Clinton was reopened. However all of the data collected from Weiner's laptop the FBI already had. So it basically was a false memo. Clearly the government is being political with their prosecution of Comey. But the decisions he made were really crazy and the book explains off of his reasons for making those decisions. For that alone its a good read whether you like or hate him.
"The Fifth Amendment requires a grand jury for a felony unless the defendant waives."??? Not in Florida state court.
Exactly! It's the law.
Post a Comment