United States v. Florida

By Jordi C. Martínez-Cid

Yesterday the Eleventh Circuit issued an opinion, authored by Judge Jordan, generally upholding Judge Middlebrooks' trial rulings and broad permanent injunction in favor of the Federal Government. Judge Middlebrooks essentially found that Florida’s Medicaid Agency violates Title II of the American with Disabilities Act ("ADA") by unnecessarily institutionalizing children with medical needs and placing others at a serious risk of institutionalization. Judge Brasher dissented, arguing that the serious risk identified by the trial court does not constitue a concrete violation of the ADA. Interestingly, Judge Brasher concludes that "It seems likely to me that, somewhere in Florida, there is a child with serious medical needs who has a strong Olmstead claim" but that the majority's opinion does not vindicate that child's rights and does not necessarily prevent the harm in the future. The opinion and dissent can be found here.