Artificial intelligence is changing the world everyday. Sometimes not for the better. A few weeks back we featured an order from Judge Matthewman sanctioning a lawyer for citing a hallucinated case. That attorney's conduct was child's play compared to the fact pattern Judge Leibowitz just confronted. A preview for you--when the lawyer at issue received an order to show cause about the use of AI-fabricated case citations, he filed a response complete with fabricated AI case quotations. Suffice it to say, things did not end well for said attorney.
Check out the order below.
DE 42_Order re AI by John Byrne on Scribd
9 comments:
Wow. Thanks for sharing. Two observations: What was this lawyer thinking? (I guess he wasn't.) Second, Judge Leibowitz is a solid writer, man. Good pick for a DJ.
Why was that jackass even citing cases in a complaint?
Gotta love the Federal District Judge in NJ who cited non-existent obviousy AI generated authorities. I guess I take some twisted comfort in knowing that practicing lawyers are not the only ones fucking this up.
Good point.
I did not know anything about Judge Leibowitz when he took the bench. Indeed, I had some minor skepticism given stories I had heard. After reading this order, a tip of the hat to the judge. We got (another) a good one on the bench.
I don’t know. I have to think that there are lots of litigants waiting for rulings on motions while we get 21 pages just to say don’t make shit up.
Chat GBT review the blog post and prepare a witty comment
Based on the order of Judge Leibowitz it is not advisable to use chat gbt for the purposes requested. Blog comments can “cause significant liability issues” Moe v. Larry and Curly, 456 F.3d 617,711 (14th Cir 2027),
Bro: some judges in our district literally never rule. You file a motion and, poof, it's off in the ether. I don't know enough about Judge Leibowitz to opinion on whether he's one of those, but I doubt it. Anyway, the facts of this particular case seem to me to be important enough to warrant this reasoned order.
David Osker Marcus with Ghislaine Maxwell after secret meeting with Trump's DOJ. Go David!
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14938725/Ghislaine-Maxwell-mystery-box-prison-secret-meeting-Donald-Trump.html
Post a Comment