There are a lot of things about the Fontainebleau hotel that are representative of Miami to me. Though criticized as flamboyant, over the top, and sometimes vulgar, it is undeniably interesting. For our youngest and most recently transplanted readers, the Fontainebleau used to have a massive Roadrunner-and-Wiley-E.-Coyote-esque trompe-l’oeil wall by Collins Avenue. Far less “glamorous” was a 14-story concrete tower built towards the beach that, according to the Third District Court of Appeal, “may have been erected partly for spite.” It cast shade, both figuratively and literally, over the Eden Roc’s old pool (they decided to build a new one). There is currently another Fontainebleau lawsuit related to spite and it involves artificial intelligence, hence the stupid title.
Rabbi Shmuley Boteach was a star in TLC’s Shalom in the Home and author of the books Kosher Sex and Kosher Jesus. The hotel alleges that Rabbi Boteach published false statements accusing it of antisemitic discrimination, and it sued for defamation and tortious interference. The rabbi counterclaimed, alleging that he was the victim of an antisemitic attack and that the hotel failed to protect him. Back in July, Magistrate Judge Fulgueira Elfenbein recommended that his answer, affirmative defenses, and counterclaim be stricken for the willful violation of the court’s order precluding him from speaking about the hotel and its counsel on social media. Judge Moore adopted the report and recommendation, and the case was eventually transferred to Judge Kuntz, who will preside over the damages trial, where punitives are at issue.
There is a long procedural history here, but AI providers apparently keep logs of deleted chats but will not release them without the user’s consent. Rabbi Boteach was ordered to consent. The hotel represented that he edited the consent form, left out his account details, and sent it through his lawyers. An AI provider’s in-house counsel emailed to explain why the form would not work. Last week, Judge Fulgueira Elfenbein ordered again that the rabbi fill out the consent form, this time without alterations. She also required the rabbi’s discovery vendor to appear at a case management conference and awarded the hotel attorneys’ fees. The history suggests to me that the rabbi really does not want those chats to come to light.
First, email used to be the best state-of-mind evidence, then WhatsApp when people mistakenly thought it was private or non-discoverable, and now AI prompts. Lots of good case law and findings in this case for those that want to pursue AI-related discovery. Will be interesting to see what, if anything, the deleted prompts say and whether it shows spite. Case number is 1:25-cv-20251.
The mural. Credit to the Miami Design Preservation League
The spite wall. Credit to Leonard Kind


