Thanks to my one of my favorite tipsters for the info.
Here's another interesting piece by Josh Blackmon on the "disrespectful dissent." As you can imagine, Justice Scalia leads the way with dissents without respect:
At the end of Justice Scalia’s dissent in Alabama Legislative Black Caucus v. Alabama, he dropped the jurisprudential mic.Accordingly, I dissent.Much like Rodney Dangerfield, Justice Breyer’s majority opinion gets no respect. Justice Scalia is no stranger to the disrespectful dissent. ***In first place (surprising no one) is Justice Scalia with 8 disrespectful dissents (counting the Alabama case). Second place was Justice Breyer with 4. RBG had had 3. Thomas and the Chief each had one. The Chief’s dissent was in his first year on the Court! Interestingly, Justices Stevens, Souter, Alito, Sotomayor, and Kagan had zero.
This obsession with stats and numbers drives me batty. Let's focus on justice.
Post a Comment