Thursday, March 27, 2008

Chief Judge Moreno allows cell phones for jurors

Big kudos to the Chief!

From Julie Kay's National Law Journal article:

Jurors and witnesses in South Florida federal trials will no longer have to bury their cellphones in the ground before entering the courthouse. U.S. District Judge Federico Moreno, chief judge for the Southern District of Florida, issued an order last week expanding the use of cellphones in the courthouse to prospective jurors, seated jurors and witnesses. The cellphones may have integrated cameras, he stated.

The issue of cellphones in federal court has been somewhat controversial in South Florida. Previous chief judges refused to even allow lawyers to carry cellphones into the courtroom, both for security concerns and to prevent photographs from being taken. Cameras are not allowed in federal courts nationwide, however a movement is now afoot to change that rule.

Since 2006, lawyers, judges, courthouse employees and federal agents have been allowed to bring cellphones into federal courthouses throughout South Florida, including in Miami, Fort Lauderdale and West Palm Beach. But jurors, reporters and others have complained about the rule. Sometimes unaware of it, visitors to the courthouses have been forced to bury their cellphones in the ground outside the courthouses and retrieve them when leaving.

In his order, Moreno noted that judges may need to contact jurors during recesses and attorneys may need to contact witnesses on short notice.

Because U.S. marshals will inspect all cellphones, security is not a concern, he stated.

"In today's modern world, security concerns are paramount," stated the order. "Yet these security concerns are satisfied by airlines, the White House, and the majority of courthouses in the United States where cellular telephones are permitted. Expanding the list to include these individuals will not diminish the security provided to the occupants of the courthouse, while at the same time enhance the availability of jurors and witnesses to participate in our court proceedings." Moreno did not extend the privilege to the use of laptops.


Anonymous said...

Next you'll have lawyers being allowed to wear brown, beige, khaki in FDC, then they'll start granting more continuances, all arraignments will be waivable, and the whole damn thing will fall apart.

Anonymous said...

Did I read that right? Jurors used to bury their cellphones?!?!

Anonymous said...

Fake Linda Greenhouse syas . . .

This is a story? The National Law Journal has nothing else to report?

South Florida Lawyers said...

Boy, it finally feels like 2002.

The Florida Masochist said...

Is there a link to the Law Journal article or is this some kind of early April Fools Day joke?

Cellular Philippine Phone said...

I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don't know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. Anyway, I'm been looking for topics as interesting as this. Looking forward to your next post.


Silke Schweizer said...

Anyway, I personally think that Chief Justice Moreno allows jurors to use mobile phones. This is unreasonable.