Wednesday, November 18, 2026

RIP Judge Posner

By John R. Byrne

Judge Richard Posner died last week at age 87. He never served on our district or circuit courts, but he was one of those rare federal judges whose name was familiar to lawyers across the country. After all, how many circuit judges outside the Eleventh Circuit can you name?

Posner was known for his brilliant legal mind, colorful opinions, and willingness to speak his mind on just about anything. Our own Judge Roy Altman recently wrote a tribute to Posner in The Free Press, focusing on that last quality.

But here's something else that was cool about Judge Posner. He occasionally stepped down from the appellate bench to preside over trials as a district court judge. And he thought other appellate judges should do the same.

As Posner once put it: "How can an appellate judge review a trial when he has never seen one, except perhaps in a movie?"

We're all familiar with district judges sitting by designation on appellate panels. But the reverse is much less common. From my admittedly limited research, I found two Eleventh Circuit judges who presided over trials while serving on the appellate court: Judges  Tjoflat and Dubina. There may be others. 

Which brings me to a question for the trial lawyers out there: If you could pick any Eleventh Circuit judge to preside over your next jury trial, who would it be? 

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

Jordan- hands down

Anonymous said...

I feel like Judge Luck would whip em into shape and push a trial along rather well. I also enjoyed the question of how many other circuit judges we could name outside the Eleventh -- I barely got 10 with a little help from knowing three names in the Ninth I wouldn't otherwise have known but for an appeal I was involved with over there.

Anonymous said...

The Altman article is less of a “tribute” to a real legend and more of “Posner did it so I can too.” Except he isn’t Posner.

Anonymous said...

Let me tell you a story about Judge Posner. I idolized him as a college student after reading his book on the impeachment of President Clinton. I wrote him a letter and asked him I could shadow him in court. To my surprise, he said yes!

For all the talk of how tough he was on attorneys who appeared in front of him (and I got to witness firsthand in 2002 while watching arguments at the 7th), he was a very nice person Super generous.

Rest easy Judge Posner.

Anonymous said...

What's interesting is that, Posner aside, I don't think I know ANY non-11th circuit judges except the ones I only know for very not good reasons--scandal, sexual harassment, or (more common) batshit decisions that are nothing but SCOTUS applications for an audience of one.

Anonymous said...

Posner never saw his role as an American judge as to advocate for the interests of a foreign country. Altman wrote a book the premise of which is Israel is being attacked by left-wing Muslim Brotherhood-sympathizing college students, and he, Altman, will humbly accept self-appointment and use his judicial prowess to determine Israel's guilt or innocence. Having done so Israel is not guilty across the board, and is in fact a shining beacon whose behavior we Americans should admire and seek to emulate.

He can think that, say it, write about it, nobody can stop him, he has life tenure. But it doesn't resemble the type of non-legal arguments Posner engaged in. Only around 20 percent of the country agrees with Altman and the facts on the ground have become increasingly impossible to spin, the most salient to most Americans being that Israel goaded our idiot president into the most unpopular war we ever chose to fight, which we then lost, the takeaway being Israel's interests plainly do not align with America's interests.

Altman's judicial legacy, until and unless he formally quits and goes into politics or lucrative civil practice, will be good smart judge who made a tremendously wrong bet on Israel. He won't get a promotion, you think even the Republicans want a confirmation hearing where Israel's conduct in Gaza and the West Bank is litigated? Zero chance.