The SDFLA Blog is dedicated to providing news and notes regarding federal practice in the Southern District of Florida. The New Times calls the blog "the definitive source on South Florida's federal court system." All tips on court happenings are welcome and will remain anonymous. Please email David Markus at dmarkus@markuslaw.com
Thursday, October 03, 2019
Breaking — Jared Strauss is your new Magistrate Judge
Strauss has been an AUSA in Broward. He graduated from Harvard Law School in 2005.
Including Judge Strauss, the last SEVEN individuals selected as United States Magistrate Judges in the Southern District of Florida have ONE thing in common: being an Assistant United States Attorney. That is one heck of a run. Rumpole doesn't need anyone to speak for him, but I believe his point was that the district court judges have made it clear that if you are not a prosecutor or a former prosecutor - don't even bother applying. And on that point, he was right.
These comments are ridiculous. Those who have never been prosecutors do not quite understand the fact that a huge portion of a Magistrate's time is reviewing search warrants, trap and trace warrants, pen registers, etc from the USAO. This does not mean that the relationship between Magistrate and USAO is always harmonious. It is not, and there is a lot of back and forth and hours for AUSA's sitting in Magistrate's offices as they review each warrant line by line with an agent present. These are documents that quite frankly, unless you have done them before, and frankly been a supervisor handling these matters like Mr Strauss, that would be difficult to just learn on the job. Mr. Strauss was the USAO's guru for all electronic search warrants for many years and worked closely with the Magistrate's to create forms and processes for items being sought by law enforcement in the 21st Century, i.e. emails, cell phone data, etc. He is very circumspect about all of this and holds himself and others to an extremely high standard before agreeing to an agent's demands for such data. He is exactly what we need in a Magistrate for the 21st Century and will continue to be a leader in this area, as well as a strong protector of Defendant's rights, as he was at the USAO. Everybody who really knows Mr. Strauss, already knows this.
Jared Strauss is a nice enough guy who has about a tenth of the experience that Steve Petri does.
ReplyDeleteHe will be great.
ReplyDeleteShouldn’t be a surprise that a court of prosecutors wants prosecutors as magistrate judges:
ReplyDeleteYet another prosecutor picked as a Mag
ReplyDeletewell, it pains me to say it:
ReplyDeleteRumpole was right
other than lurana snow, dave brannon, bruce reinhart, william matthewman, pat hunt, yeah dumpole has a point
ReplyDelete11:25 HUH?
ReplyDeleteIncluding Judge Strauss, the last SEVEN individuals selected as United States Magistrate Judges in the Southern District of Florida have ONE thing in common: being an Assistant United States Attorney. That is one heck of a run.
Rumpole doesn't need anyone to speak for him, but I believe his point was that the district court judges have made it clear that if you are not a prosecutor or a former prosecutor - don't even bother applying. And on that point, he was right.
Judge Louis was on the CJA panel for years. She is also a former prosecutor, but so are a ton of defense attorneys.
ReplyDeleteJudge Otazo Reyes was not a former prosecutor last time I checked
ReplyDeleteditto brannon WPB, Hunt in FTL and Matthewman
facts can be so annoying
Snow was an superpivor at US attorney's office when she became a mag.
ReplyDeletehttps://www.sun-sentinel.com/news/fl-xpm-1985-11-15-8502200905-story.html
Hopefully Magistrate Strauss will bring the same honor to the bench as Johnny K.
ReplyDeletehttps://www.cato.org/multimedia/cato-daily-podcast/are-disproportionate-number-federal-judges-former-prosecutors
ReplyDelete9:33 it shouldn't be a surprise. the pd office here gets no respect and for good reason.
ReplyDeleteWhat a joke this court is. Embarrassing.
ReplyDeleteThese comments are ridiculous. Those who have never been prosecutors do not quite understand the fact that a huge portion of a Magistrate's time is reviewing search warrants, trap and trace warrants, pen registers, etc from the USAO. This does not mean that the relationship between Magistrate and USAO is always harmonious. It is not, and there is a lot of back and forth and hours for AUSA's sitting in Magistrate's offices as they review each warrant line by line with an agent present. These are documents that quite frankly, unless you have done them before, and frankly been a supervisor handling these matters like Mr Strauss, that would be difficult to just learn on the job. Mr. Strauss was the USAO's guru for all electronic search warrants for many years and worked closely with the Magistrate's to create forms and processes for items being sought by law enforcement in the 21st Century, i.e. emails, cell phone data, etc. He is very circumspect about all of this and holds himself and others to an extremely high standard before agreeing to an agent's demands for such data. He is exactly what we need in a Magistrate for the 21st Century and will continue to be a leader in this area, as well as a strong protector of Defendant's rights, as he was at the USAO. Everybody who really knows Mr. Strauss, already knows this.
ReplyDelete