There has been a bunch of news about this Order out of Broward state court, disqualifying the state attorney's office for listening in on attorney-client conversations in a first degree murder prosecution.
The State took a breath-taking position -- because the call originated from jail, the inmate waived the attorney-client privilege. The judge quickly dismissed this position. The defense argued that the case should be dismissed for the egregious violation. The judge didn't go that far, but did disqualify the entire prosecution office from the case.
Two questions for you. Does this happen over here? And if it did ever happen, what would the likely result be. I put two polls for you below:
The SDFLA Blog is dedicated to providing news and notes regarding federal practice in the Southern District of Florida. The New Times calls the blog "the definitive source on South Florida's federal court system." All tips on court happenings are welcome and will remain anonymous. Please email David Markus at dmarkus@markuslaw.com
You can be damn sure they do listen to the calls, or at least the agents do. It is a huge problem which will never come to light because the agents would undoubtedly lie about it, even if it was inadvertent.
ReplyDeleteRead the order. Whoever the prosecutor is, they should be brought up on charges before the Bar.
ReplyDeleteThey can listen on my calls all they want.
ReplyDeleteDefendant: "What are we gonna do?"
Me. How the fu*k should I know?
D: Is the prosecutor any good.
Me.: They suck.
D. What about the Judge?
Me. A political hack. Couldn't make a living as a lawyer.
D. So what's the defense?
Me. I dunno. You did it. You tell me.
I mean really, what are they going to find out that they do not already know?
PS. For all you prospective clients out there who now, having seen my attorney-client relations in action, can't wait to hire me, much like Bernie Madoff, I am somewhat selective on who I will work for. So you'll have to settle for Mr. Markus.
ReplyDeleteAs a former AUSA, I had many opportunities to listen to attorney-client conversations caught on tape. It never occurred to me to actually do so--even when the client (defendant) was in jail and talking on a cell phone in violation of prison rules. It's outrageous to learn that there may be prosecutors out there who think it's okay to violate such a privilege, absent some extraordinary circumstance (for instance, probable cause to believe that the attorney is involved in some illegal conduct.) I would hope that such conduct would be reported to the state bar and the Office of Professional Responsibility.
ReplyDelete